The financial fireworks continue. Over the weekend, the Europeans found that they weren’t insulated from the crisis at all:
“Germany is now in the hot seat. The collapse of a rescue deal for Hypo Real Estate on Saturday threatens a €400bn (£311bn) bankruptcy that nearly matches the Lehman Brothers debacle for sheer scale.
Chancellor Angela Merkel has been forced to pull her head out of the sand, guaranteeing all German savings, a day after she rebuked Ireland for doing much the same thing. Reality intrudes.
During the past week, we have tipped over the edge, into the middle of the abyss. Systemic collapse is in full train. The Netherlands has just rushed through a second, more sweeping nationalisation of Fortis. Ireland and Greece have had to rescue all their banks. Iceland is facing an Argentine denouement.”
More by Ambrose Evans-Pritchard (who seems to be relishing his role as Jeremiah) at the Daily Telegraph.
Comment:
While I agree in general, I think the hysteria is misplaced. Things aren’t good, but we are only making it worse by fanning public hysteria. The essential problem is that banks are fearful of counter-party risk, because the rating agencies weren’t doing their jobs – so much for more regulation). Many of these assets are illiquid because they are marked up too highly. That includes houses. Prices are deflating, but they are still not back at realistic values. Mark them down and you will find buyers in the market. Instead, everyone is trying to keep prices at artificial levels by getting the government to buy them (and here, in the US, we can print money to support any price level). Ergo – confidence grows less and less, as prices and values become even more completely unhinged.
That’s why, this morning, the Dow is down, sinking below 10,000 for the first time in 4 years. I want to say, I told you so, to the entire political, academic, financial, and cultural establishment which has been out in force telling us to sign that bill, or else.
And remember Jim Cramer saying he liked this market just this past June? Well, today Cramer’s telling people who need their money in the next five years to pull it out of the market asap. Almost makes you think we hit a bottom (only half kidding).
Unlike Cramer, Nadeem Walayat, a trader, has been right on the money. We are at 1929, he says, and yet, we’re not – because, today, it’s not a stock market crisis but a banking crisis. Walayat predicts a two-year recession.
Personally, and here, Evans-Pritchard’s use of the phrase shock and awe seems like a bit of a give away, I think there is more to this crisis than meets the eye. Remain skeptical – especially, when anything involves trampling the constitution and creating ever more powerful financial czars….
Just remember – as this piece says – a substantial part of the media shills for Wall Street and the government. They either print outright falsehoods, naively repeat what they are told, or co-opt the arguments of people who are right by appropriating a part of what they say but giving it their own misleading spin.
As for punitive measures for what’s happened, Michael Brush at MSN Money Central has a good piece on how CEO’s made out while their companies were tanking. He doesn’t have much hope that legislation will get the bad guys to cough up their ill-gotten gains but he does have a couple of links for you to get through to the government.
Regulatory overhaul is not the answer (although a few rules do need to be reinstated). Look at what’s happening in Europe? No lack of regulation there. And, the Eurocrats are even turning their backs on a Eurozone rescue modeled after the American.
“I reject a European shield because we as Germans do not want to pay into a big pot where we do not have control and do not know where German money might be used,”
says Peer Steinsbruch, Germany’s Minister of Finance…..suddenly, quite the nationalist.
I follow your skepticism with the power being created by the new financial czars and their augmented power through the reduction in oversight and diminishing power of the Constitution.
The ideas that the top down rescue attempts will work have been attempted and have proven to be ill advised. Based on the second law of dynamics, it is impossible for the home values in so many countries throughout the world, which have become out of touch with the system as a whole, can be stabilized and supported at their current levels. These bad loans and many out of touch property values should be considered a virus or infection to the system as a whole and understood to be the systemic breakdown of the success of the system or economy itself. We saw much evidence of this in the boom of the internet, as well. Much of these systemic issues fall right in line with your book, “Mobs, Messiahs, and Markets”.
I discuss this a bit on my blog today in much more detail at http://bdgroupllc.blogspot.com
It is in emergence theory that the control of this system can not be attained, as there is no one step cure to the macro issues at hand. By stabilizing, or bailing out, the banking institutions there will be some comfort to the “hosts” of the problem. The individual community and its citizens (or micro organisms), will take the brunt of this damage control, hereby alluding that the trickle down theories do not work.
Hey Doug –
Great post. I checked it out.
I do think – as you do – that interesting things could come out of this, if the government wasn’t intervening. As it is, I think they make matters worse, because guess what, now everyone is waiting to be bailed out….why would they go bankrupt when the taxpayer can step in?
Next, someone will say Jesus said forgive us our debts…oh, I forgot. Someone over on the left already said that. They forgot to mention that Jesus was teaching in the context of Mosaic law, which he clearly said had to be fulfilled. Somehow I think forgiving the mortgage loans of yuppie speculators and Wall Street financiers was not what he was advocating. And lest I be accused of class warfare, I don’t think he’d advocate forgiving student loans and credit card debt either. Some relief for those with genuine problems is fine, or for those who were cheated or had predatory terms.
But bilking your creditors is theft, and last I looked, not something advocated in any major religion.