Book Business Takes Another Hit..from Walmart

Rick Ackerman:

The giant retailer’s shot-across-the-bow – offering the top ten best-sellers for $10 — came just in time to devastate book stores during the holiday shopping season. Stores of every size will be vulnerable — from independents who have been savvy enough to survive competition from Amazon, to the largest vendors, including Borders, Barnes & Noble, Target, and even Amazon itself. No seller will make money at that price, not even publishers, but that is of little concern to Wal-Mart, which seeks only to demonstrate in as brutal a manner as possible that it will not be undersold. Nor can independent booksellers simply buy copies from Wal-Mart to resell, since $10 best sellers are being limited to just a few copies per buyer. The predictable result six to twelve months down the road is that many book stores both big and small will be closing, adding hugely to a retail vacancy rate that is already approaching depressionary levels.

Wal-Mart is all good cheer in promoting its everyday values, but there is no longer any denying that its primary goal is to drive all of its competitors into the ground. This strategy will no doubt be abetted by Chinese manufacturers eager to unload goods into a weak U.S. market at any cost. When Wal-Mart eventually succeeds at it, we can be certain that “everyday low prices” will be superseded in practice by prices reflecting whatever the traffic will bear. Wal-Mart has the reach, the naked ambition and the pricing power to bankrupt nearly any competitor in any business, from consumer electronics, to Halloween costumes, to funeral services, to pharmaceuticals, to lawn furniture. A decade ago, a grassroots movement to hold the line against Wal-Mart’s relentless expansion died after the retailer won some local skirmishes. Now the company is too big to oppose, a vital appendage of nearly every town in which it operates. America has paid a huge price for those everyday values.”

One thought on “Book Business Takes Another Hit..from Walmart

  1. Eeek… that’s one article that’s trembling terribly in irrational fear. Sticking to the main topic of book-selling (and thus avoiding all the sweeping ideological generalizations of the second paragraph), it’s absurd to blame Walmart in any way for the decline of the obsolete book industry (which includes this weird fad hybrid that is DRM-ed ebooks), except to say it’s helping it transition a little faster into reality.

    Or was your intention to point out the inconsistency of (a) praising competition to provide better products/services and (b) demonizing the competition for providing better products/services. 😛

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *